Mike,
You should try Bromelain instead of Ibuprofen at least for a while anyway. I was prescribed Ibuprofen a long time ago for the same problem, and to be honest didn't find it much use. I didn't know about Bromelain at that time. In my humble opinion it has superior anti-inflammatory properties to the orthodox drug, without any of the potential side effects of such a high dose i.e. stomach problems. Take 500mg twice daily on an empty stomach and give it a week. I sincerely wish you all the best.
P.S. I wouldn't worry about the Fenugreek at the present time. It may not do a lot for mere inflammation, if that's the source of your problem.
